Cayuga Playground

The pirate theme here is done right — not just a coat of paint, but actual character throughout the climbing structures that kids genuinely get into. There are two separate play areas, which is great if you’ve got a toddler and an older kid in tow, since they each get something appropriately challenging. Swing options are solid, with diaper swings for the little ones and a tire swing that the bigger kids will fight over. The real bonus is that you’re steps from the lake and a proper beach, so you can easily stretch the trip into a half-day if the weather cooperates. Locals know to come early on summer weekends before it gets crowded.